Global Include is good. GA_env is unset!

PBS KIDS GO! Illustration of the New York City skyline Activities Illustration of the New York City skyline
Big Apple History -- From New York to Your Town Illustration of the New York City skyline

Early New York
Coming to America
Building the Big Apple
Arts & Entertainment
Business & Politics
New York Living
Parents & Teachers
Parents and Teachers - Lesson Plans - New York Living
Lesson Plan: Neighborhood Portrait back to Parents and Teachers
Overview Prep Steps Worksheets Putting it all Together



Grade Level:
4 to 8 (middle school)

Subject Matter:
social studies, civics

Time Allotment:
approximately 2 class periods

Overview

Beginning with a discussion of Manhattan's Lower East Side immigrant community at the turn of the century, this activity asks students to think about what makes communities special. It then asks them to think about their own community with one basic question in mind: what makes it special? As the activity suggests, the answer is not so simple.

The activity is divided into several parts. First, students are asked to come up with questions that will help them explore what makes their community special. Second, it shows them ways they can go out into the community to come up with answers to those questions. Finally, it offers ideas on how to present their answers to others in the form of a visual and written presentation.

Prep

Start this activity by having your students look at the the articles "Tenement Life," "Salesmen of the Streets," "Streets and Roofs," "Radicals," and "Crowds and Creativity."

Hold a class discussion about the Lower East Side that focuses on the question: what made this community special? You might want to review the questions suggested to the students in their activity plan. A few important ones include: What kinds of people lived there? What was the physical environment like? What was the social and creative life like? How did all these things come together to give the Lower East Side its special feel?

Next, you may want to move on to a discussion of what community means. Is it simply a physical space -- everyone living in a certain area? Or is it something more? This should also help the students focus on the parameters of their own study, especially if they do not live in a self-contained neighborhood or town. Defining the boundaries of their community is a prerequisite for this activity.

Finally, you might want to suggest a few things that make the students' communities special. But don't do too much on this or you won't leave the students enough room to answer the question on their own. One suggestion is for you or your students to describe what made a community you or they once lived in special.

Steps

This activity could be done by individual students, but it would probably be more fun and productive to do it in groups.

  1. As noted above, this activity asks students to ask and answer the question: What makes their community special? Neither the question nor the answer can be simple or one-dimensional, of course. Students are presented with a whole host of questions to think about. They are then told to go out into the community to answer the questions by collecting evidence. Once they have collected evidence, they are then offered the opportunity of creating a visual and written presentation that reflects their particular slant on the question of what makes their community special.

  2. Before having them go out into the community, you may want to review the questions presented to the students in step 2. You also may want to add a few of their own. Most students will probably have no problem collecting the visual evidence -- taking pictures, making drawings, or collecting material like street posters, cut-outs from the local newspapers, and other paraphernalia for a collage. (One suggestion: they can go to the local library or historical society to collect material -- in the form of photocopies -- for collage.)

  3. Students may have less of an idea about how to take notes or interview people who live in the community. You might want to go over the different kinds of people they could talk to: neighbors, friends, storekeepers, policemen, and other government officials. And also, the kinds of questions to focus on. These include basic informational questions that place that person in the community -- how long they have lived there, what they do, etc. -- and impressionistic questions -- how they feel about the community, how it has changed, how they think it's special.

  4. In presenting their materials, students can let their imaginations take over. However, you may want to provide a little guidance to help them create a coherent presentation. Some things to consider are: are they trying to tell a story of their community over time or do they want to present a snapshot of the community today? Do they want to focus broadly on the whole community, or on one aspect of it, such as its people or its physical structures?

    You may also want to offer students a place to present their materials, either in the classroom or the school at large. Or perhaps you want to help the students find another public place to put up their presentations -- like city hall or a local restaurant or bank. Then, of course, there is always the possibility of putting the presentation onto a Web site.
Worksheets

Neighborhood Portrait

Putting It All Together

The streets were filthy. The housing was sub-standard. The poverty was everywhere. And, in the early 1900s, it may have been the most crowded place on Earth. But New York's Lower East Side was also a place of great creativity and energy -- in the arts, in business, in politics. It was, in short, a very special community. People felt like they were part of something bigger. Today, with suburban sprawl and new forms of media, the idea of community is being redefined. This activity and lesson has introduced students to some of the different aspects of the concept of community.