Global Include is good. GA_env is unset!

PBS KIDS GO! Illustration of the New York City skyline Activities Illustration of the New York City skyline
Big Apple History -- From New York to Your Town Illustration of the New York City skyline

Early New York
Coming to America
Building the Big Apple
Arts & Entertainment
Business & Politics
New York Living
Parents & Teachers
Parents and Teachers - Lesson Plans - Early New York
Lesson Plan: History or Mis-story? back to Parents and Teachers
Overview Prep Steps Worksheets Putting it all Together



Grade Level:
4 to 8 (middle school)

Subject Matter:
American history, folklore

Time Allotment:
approximately 10-15 minutes a week for 15 weeks

Overview


In this activity, students explore some of our country's "founding myths" and legends by participating in an online poll. For example, did George Washington really chop down a cherry tree, then confess to his father about the deed, saying, "I cannot tell a lie"? Did the Dutch buy Manhattan from the American Indians for the equivalent of $24?

Prep


Begin by having your students read the article "Father Knickerbocker."

Lead a class discussion. You may wish to discuss questions such as:

  • What legends have you heard about these heroes in American history: George Washington, Betsy Ross, Paul Revere, and Abraham Lincoln? Do you think these stories are true?

  • Myths and legends often promote cultural messages. What are the moral lessons being promoted by legends such as the one in which George Washington chops down his father's cherry tree?
Steps

  1. Go to the "History or Mis-story?" activity page to see the myth-of-the-week. Have one of your students read it aloud to the class. After some class discussion to ensure that everyone understands the people and situation mentioned in the story, take a vote in your class to decide: Is the story true or false?

  2. If your students would like to research more about the subject of myths in early America, these books are a good place to start:

    Shenkman, Richard. LEGENDS, LIES AND CHERISHED MYTHS OF AMERICAN HISTORY (HarperCollins, 1988).

    Loewen, James W. LIES MY TEACHER TOLD ME: EVERYTHING YOUR AMERICAN HISTORY BOOK GOT WRONG (The New Press, 1995).

    Davis, Kenneth C. DON'T KNOW MUCH ABOUT HISTORY (Avon Books, 1995).
Putting It All Together


In this activity, you have learned that some of America's treasured historical legends have little basis in truth. By learning more about American "founding myths," we have hopefully sparked your curiosity and honed your sense of skepticism. Remember: Just because a story is popular doesn't mean that it's necessarily true.