Global Include is good. GA_env is unset!

PBS KIDS GO! Illustration of the New York City skyline Activities Illustration of the New York City skyline
Big Apple History -- From New York to Your Town Illustration of the New York City skyline

Early New York
Coming to America
Building the Big Apple
Arts & Entertainment
Business & Politics
New York Living
Parents & Teachers
Parents and Teachers - Lesson Plans - Buildign the Big Apple
Lesson Plan: United We Stand? back to Parents and Teachers
Overview Prep Steps Worksheets Putting it all Together



Grade Level:
4 to 8 (middle school)

Subject Matter:
social studies, civics

Time Allotment:
approximately 1 class period

Overview

In this activity, students are asked to think about the consolidation that led to the creation of greater New York City in 1898, and what would happen if their own class, school, or community united with its neighbor or neighbors. The activity also asks the student to assess the pros and cons of such a consolidation. Finally, the activity asks them to debate the question among themselves and to make a recommendation -- consolidation or continued separation.

Prep

Begin by having the students read the articles "The Story of Brooklyn" and "Across Five Boroughs."

Hold a discussion about the 1898 consolidation of New York. Why did it occur? Who was behind it ? Who was for it, and why? Who was against it, and why? How has it benefitted the people of New York? Which groups within the city have benefitted most? Who has been hurt?

Now have the students focus on the issue of consolidation generally. Is bigger always better? If so, why? And when or where? If not, why not? And when or where? Have them consider issues of cost, efficiency, identity and loss of identity, and local say and power versus enhanced power at the state and national level.

Steps

This activity is best done as a class activity, with students breaking up into groups for the debate.

  1. Break the class up into six groups -- two devoted to class consolidation (one pro and one con), two to school consolidation, and two to community consolidation. Have each group research the pros and cons of consolidation. In the activity Web page, students are encouraged to talk to people -- both those who would be affected by the consolidation and, for objectivity, others who would not.

  2. Once they are ready, have them debate the subject. You could also have the rest of the class vote on consolidation.

    Of course, you could also invite other classes, schools, or members of other communities -- that is, those considered for consolidation -- to participate, either as spectators of, or participants in, the debate.
Worksheets

United We Stand?

Putting It All Together

Consolidation goes on around us all the time. Usually, it involves business. One company buys out another; a chain of stores replaces independent shops. On the one hand, consolidation means bigger stores, with more selection and lower prices. But chain stores also can mean less local control, fewer economic benefits for the community, and a loss of the personal touch. Consolidation is part of modern life. But is it for better or worse?