Global Include is good. GA_env is unset!

PBS KIDS GO! Illustration of the New York City skyline Activities Illustration of the New York City skyline
Big Apple History -- From New York to Your Town Illustration of the New York City skyline

Early New York
Coming to America
Building the Big Apple
Arts & Entertainment
Business & Politics
New York Living
Illustration of a taxi cab
Activities - Building the Big Apple back to Activities Intro
Focus On Separation And Unity
United We Stand?

Hands Across The Water
Number 1
In the 1890s, when Manhattan leaders suggested that surrounding areas join it to form greater New York City, they were mostly met with applause. Communities in the Bronx, Queens, and Staten Island liked the idea of sharing Manhattan's tax monies and other resources. But the biggest of the communities, Brooklyn, was already a city of its own with almost a million people counted as citizens. Brooklyn residents were not so sure they wanted to partner-up with Manhattan. City leaders worried about losing control over their city. Depending on whom you ask, those fears have or have not come true.

Unity can bring strength through size, but it can also lead to a loss of local power and identity. This tension is not unique to New York, of course, the entire United States of America fought a civil war in part over this issue.

What about your own community? Your community has its identity and is surrounded by other communities, which are also autonomous. In this activity, you will explore what might happen if your community unified with another.

Weigh The Pros And The Cons
2
Get a group of your friends together and talk about what other towns or communities in your area could join with yours. Then divide yourselves into two groups: one devoted to merging your two communities, and one opposed to it. Each group should research the pros and cons of consolidation (joining) but should try to make a case supporting their chosen side. Think about costs, efficiency, identity, control, and independence among other factors.
Debate
3
Once both groups have the evidence they need, come together and debate each other! After you've heard the arguments presented by both sides you will have a good sense of what Brooklyn citizens faced when they had to choose to join or not to join Manhattan.